Print the page
Increase font size
When Seasonality Meets "Situationality"

Posted November 03, 2025

Enrique Abeyta

By Enrique Abeyta

When Seasonality Meets "Situationality"

To most investors, seasonality sounds like voodoo. But there’s nothing mystical about it.

When you look through historical stock performance, the market clearly tends to perform better during certain times of the year.

November is the best month of the year for the market, and December is another seasonally strong month.

Taxes, year-end compensation for money managers, and earnings all play a role. Whatever the reason, stocks often finish the year on a high note.

But there’s another force at work that’s just as important — what I call “situationality.”

This is simply the effect of recent stock market performance on what happens next.

With October in the books, the S&P 500 and Dow have now logged six straight months of gains (seven for the Nasdaq).

So the question now is: how does the market perform heading into year-end when it’s already running hot?

Let’s take a look at what the data says.

A Rare Setup for Year-End Gains

The combination of seasonality and situationality over the next two months is very bullish for the stock market.

Here are some good charts from one of my favorite market strategists, Ryan Detrick from Carson Investment Research.

The first one shows how the stock market performs in November and December when the S&P is up more than 15% year-to-date by the end of October.

On the chart, you can see that November is up 81% of the time, December is up 71% of the time, and the index is up 95% of the time with the two months combined.

The S&P 500 is also up by almost 5% on average. Pretty good for just two months!

Here is another one from a technical analyst named Seth Golden.

This table shows the performance of the S&P 500 in November and December, when the period from May to October is up 10% or more.

This has happened 12 times since 1950. And each of those 12 times, the stock market has been higher in the final two months.

Here is another similar analysis from Ryan Detrick. It shows the final two-month performance of the S&P 500 when it’s seen positive performance each month from May to October.

This is only the fourth time this has happened in the last 75 years.

Each of the previous three times this happened, the S&P has been up over the next two months with an average return of 6%.

These analyses are so powerful because they combine the current situationality with strong seasonality.

Where We Go From Here

Here are a few more charts showing the seasonality of year-end stock market performance.

This first shows that last Monday (Oct. 27) is the date when we typically see the final bottom on the S&P 500 before it grinds higher into the end of the year.

Here is another one that shows the performance of the stock market going forward historically based on three-month rolling periods. It shows the period from November to January.

You can see on the chart that this period is by far the best for the stock market, especially the tech-heavy Nasdaq Composite.

And finally, here is one last chart from Ryan Detrick at Carson. This one combines even more about the situationality.

It combines market performance for every year, the past 20 years, this year of a presidential cycle, a year following a +20% year, and a positive January/February.

It then builds a composite to show what happens next.

History would imply we have a great couple of months ahead of us.

The combination of seasonality and situationality has lined up perfectly this year — and history suggests it’s a powerful setup.

So game on!

Tariff Tantrum Redux

Tariff Tantrum Redux

Posted February 23, 2026

By Enrique Abeyta

Trump is doubling down on his trade agenda after the Supreme Court smacked down his tariffs.
The Weight of Nothing

The Weight of Nothing

Posted February 20, 2026

By Nick Riso

The S&P 500 nearly broke 7,000 points this week, until it ran into an invisible trillion-dollar wall.
“Luck Is Not Real”

“Luck Is Not Real”

Posted February 19, 2026

By Enrique Abeyta

Luck is simply our perception of what’s happening around us — not a force that determines our success.
The S&P 500 Lies

The S&P 500 Lies

Posted February 18, 2026

By Nick Riso

The S&P 500 index has ceased functioning as an accurate measurement tool. And it’s all because of concentration.
The Kill Switch: How a Hidden Algorithm Is Blowing Up Boring Stocks

The Kill Switch: How a Hidden Algorithm Is Blowing Up Boring Stocks

Posted February 16, 2026

By Enrique Abeyta

Here’s how leverage, crowding, and hard stops can overwhelm even the most solid fundamentals.
Snapback Trade Watchlist: HOOD, SHOP, TOST

Snapback Trade Watchlist: HOOD, SHOP, TOST

Posted February 13, 2026

By Greg Guenthner

It’s starting to feel like snapback season, when you can make serious money betting on sharp comeback moves.