Print the page
Increase font size
The GameStop Gambit

Posted December 16, 2024

Enrique Abeyta

By Enrique Abeyta

The GameStop Gambit

Successful trading is all about finding asymmetric risk/reward setups.

That simply means a situation where your potential gain from an investment is far greater than your potential loss.

One of the most intriguing asymmetric bets in the market right now is GameStop (GME).

Now, I know what you’re probably thinking…

The meme stock king… that GameStop? Could any self-respecting trader seriously consider buying GME?

The answer is absolutely YES.

I’ll tell you why in just a moment. But before I do, allow me to share an important trading lesson.

Trade Stocks, Not Companies

As a trader, it’s important to remember that stocks are not companies. What do I mean by that?

Well, if you listen to “smart” money, they’ll tell you that you own a piece of a company when you buy a share of stock. And this is technically true.

They’ll also tell you that the value of a stock should be the discounted value of the future cash flows.

We don’t need to dissect that whole statement for our purposes today. But basically, it means a stock should be worth the pile of cash it will throw off in the future.

Now, 99% of professional financial advisors, economists, academics, and media pundits will say this is gospel truth. It isn’t.

It’s actually a concept that can lose you a lot of money and keep you from some of the best opportunities.

I guarantee the ONE trader out of 100 who will tell you differently is the most successful you will ever meet.

These are the kind of traders that successfully manage billions of dollars — traders like me.

The truth that the “smart” money doesn’t want you to know (or doesn’t understand themselves) is that a stock is worth whatever anyone is willing to pay.

My favorite example is the e-commerce giant Amazon.com (AMZN).

The stock has gone from $0.075 per share at the IPO to a recent high of over $230. That’s a 306,566% return if you want help with the math.

In that time, Amazon has never returned a single cent of the cash it has generated to investors. It bought back a little bit of stock, but never once paid a dividend.

If the value of the company is the value of the cash flows, when (if ever) do we get to see these actual cash flows?

The reality is that unless a stock gets bought out or goes bankrupt, the value is simply what the market is willing to pay for it.

The “smart” money doesn’t want you to know this, because it means you stop paying them fees and do it yourself.

Once you understand this, you’ll become a much more successful trader.

This realization is like unplugging from the Matrix. Think of me as your Morpheus, showing you what’s really happening with stocks.

Now let’s get back to GameStop…

An Asymmetric Opportunity

I don’t have the space to cover the longer history of GameStop as a meme stock. But let’s go back to earlier this year.

In May, the internet influencer Roaring Kitty sent GME stock soaring once again after returning to the scene. Here’s the stock chart.

You can see that the stock went nuts after this happened.

What’s most interesting is that GameStop CEO Ryan Cohen took advantage of the situation and issued a ton of stock.

The company used a novel strategy called an at-the-market offering to issue more than 120 million shares, raising over $4 billion of cash in the last six months.

When the company reported results last week, it reported over $4.6 billion of cash or cash equivalents on the balance sheet.

That’s balanced against basically no debt (under $20 million) and is a little bit more than $10 per share.

GameStop’s results were bad. Sales for its legacy video game retail business were down over 30% year-over-year.

You’d think the company must be hemorrhaging money as a result, right? Well, it actually reported a net income of $17 million during the most recent quarter.

The $33 million loss from its retail operations was offset by $55 million of interest income on its huge pile of cash.

Over the last several years, the company has done a great job of cutting costs and reducing its cash burn.

It burned only $27 million last year while producing almost $100 million of cash in the last two quarters.

I’m sure GameStop wishes its core business was profitable. But it isn’t going out of business anytime soon.

Now, this is where it gets really interesting…

When you buy GME shares today, you’re basically buying an option on what its savvy CEO will do with the cash in the future.

Of course, that option isn’t free. The cash pile is worth $10 per share and you pay $30 per share. It’s a $20 per share (or $8 billion) premium. That’s a LOT!

Do I think it’s the right amount? I don’t know, but I don’t think it matters.

But it is the right price in the sense that there are millions of shares transacting at these levels right now. Remember one of my favorite sayings: PRICE = TRUTH.

I think that Ryan Cohen will do something with the cash sooner rather than later. I also think he will do something that will benefit the stock.

He’s the largest shareholder with over 36 million common shares and more exposure with his compensation.

Here’s one idea…

A Rocketship to the Moon

What if he went out and bought Bitcoin?

He doesn’t have to use all of the cash. But he could easily spend $1-2 billion and still have plenty of ammo to do other stuff.

I think the stock would fly if he did this and could see $60 again as it did in May.

And what if he took advantage of that opportunity again and issued more stock, or did a convertible bond like Michael Saylor has successfully done at MicroStrategy (MSTR)?

The stock would go ballistic!

Does any of this create real economic value? That remains to be seen.

But MSTR is sitting on a massive gain on the Bitcoin it bought over the years, so it has created real value.

Is it sustainable? Does it fit the “smart” money’s academic models? Maybe not.

But remember, we aren’t here to sit for a financial exam. We’re here to identify great risk/reward opportunities and MAKE MONEY!

I'm Buying Stocks Hand Over Fist

I'm Buying Stocks Hand Over Fist

Posted December 23, 2024

By Enrique Abeyta

Last week’s stock selloff might just be the best Christmas gift investors could have asked for. Here’s one way to quadruple your returns as the broad market snaps back.
50-Year Storm Hits the Dow…

50-Year Storm Hits the Dow…

Posted December 20, 2024

By Greg Guenthner

Perhaps the market has placed the melt-up on hold. But that’s no excuse to discount a year-end Santa Claus rally.
Yesterday’s Selloff Triggered a Rare Setup

Yesterday’s Selloff Triggered a Rare Setup

Posted December 19, 2024

By Enrique Abeyta

Drops like yesterday’s don’t happen often. And history shows they usually snap back, especially this time of year.
‘Tis the Season for a Snapback

‘Tis the Season for a Snapback

Posted December 13, 2024

By Greg Guenthner

The market is offering an array of choices as the melt-up embraces the holiday cheer.
Murder in Manhattan

Murder in Manhattan

Posted December 12, 2024

By Enrique Abeyta

History doesn’t repeat itself, but it often rhymes. What a CEO’s death reveals about the state of America and the stock market’s future returns.
This One Stock Can Keep You Ahead of a Cooling Melt-Up

This One Stock Can Keep You Ahead of a Cooling Melt-Up

Posted December 10, 2024

By Greg Guenthner

The crypto currency and AI-fueled rally will eventually lose steam. When it does, precious metals stocks could take the hot seat.