Print the page
Increase font size
Tariff 2.0: A Pattern in the Chaos

Posted April 07, 2025

Enrique Abeyta

By Enrique Abeyta

Tariff 2.0: A Pattern in the Chaos

You may be ready to move on from tariffs, but the market certainly isn’t.

Last week’s tariff shocks — which sent the Nasdaq into a bear market and caused the worst one-day drop in the S&P since 2020 — are nowhere near over.

Hopefully, you took some time this weekend to unplug and reset. But I understand if you're still feeling a little rattled.

So let's take a minute today to step back and put this all in perspective. And no, I don't mean cracking open the history book and analyzing tariffs from over a century ago!

To make sense of the current moment, we only have to turn back the clock to the last time Trump sent investors into a panic with tariffs.

Trump Tariffs 1.0

Back in early 2018, Trump triggered a big selloff in the stock market after making comments at the Davos economic forum. This caused the stock market to plummet for the next few weeks.

Here is a chart of the S&P 500 during that period.

We have circled the selloff in a red circle. The S&P 500 sold off 12% in just a few days.

The bottom chart is the relative strength index (or RSI), which is a measure of investor enthusiasm.

A high number (above 70, the red line on the chart) shows investor exuberance. A low number (below 30, the green line) shows investor pessimism. Low numbers can be very good buy signals.

There are a lot of similarities between this selloff and what we are seeing today.

Back in 2018, the stock market went from a very overbought position — distance from the 50-day moving average and high RSI — to immediately being oversold.

The S&P 500 traded down to the 200-day moving average and bounced +9% and back above the 50-day and 100-day moving averages.

From there, it would retest the 200-day moving average and then trade in a very choppy manner for three months before settling down.

After that, the stock market went to new highs.

Now let’s look at the chart of the S&P 500 going into this most recent Trump tariff situation.

It is spaced out differently, but it looks similar.

We had a very overbought stock market in the months leading up to the tariff talk. This then resulted in a rapid selloff where the S&P 500 fell 10% and traded below the 200-day moving average.

Then there was a multi-day rally of 5% and back to that 200-day moving average.

On the charts, you can clearly see some similarities and a few key differences. This time, the situation has taken longer to develop.

The selloff has also done more damage with the S&P 500 trading below the 200-day moving average and staying below it — especially after the big recent announcement.

This all makes sense as the news is also different. The 2018 Trump tariff initiatives were a fraction of what he is trying to do now.

The stock market is accurately responding to the magnitude of the difference.

I think the stock market reaction is appropriate, but the previous period is an important point of comparison.

What happened back then was that Trump came out much more aggressive than anyone thought possible with his tariff program.

This is why the stock market sold off 12% in just a week. That is a steeper move than what just happened.

In that case, however, he rolled out his plans in the following months. And while they were still aggressive, he took actions that were less than his initial bid.

This is how he has consistently negotiated throughout his five decades in business. This style of negotiation is his trademark.

He comes in much more aggressively than anyone ever anticipated and essentially acts like the “crazy kid” in the schoolyard.

Then once everyone is on their back foot, he proceeds to hammer out deals that make sense for both parties.

It is what he did in business for decades and what he did in his last administration.

We have a ton of real-world data and experience that explains his actions.

Will This Time Be Different?

Without a doubt, this move into the tariff space is MUCH bigger than last time. To use his favorite adjective — it is “huge!”

The magnitude of the initial bid is 10 times (or more) than what he was trying to do previously. He also is going much broader than before.

In response, the stock market is beginning to reflect the larger scope. It clearly could get worse before it gets better.

In the previous period, we saw that it took three months for the market to digest the news.

The same could happen here, if not even longer.

While this will be painful for long-term investors, it will provide many short-term opportunities for traders.

The future is unknown, but the past can give us guidance — and we can use that to figure out our next move!

Beware the “Backdoor Correction”

Beware the “Backdoor Correction”

Posted October 21, 2025

By Ian Culley

The S&P 500 doesn’t tell the story, but stocks have been correcting for weeks.
The Leverage Trap: A Painful Lesson in Risk

The Leverage Trap: A Painful Lesson in Risk

Posted October 17, 2025

By Greg Guenthner

Even in a rip-roaring bull market like the one we’re in now, you have to know how to protect yourself.
4 Hard Truths for a Parabolic Market

4 Hard Truths for a Parabolic Market

Posted October 16, 2025

By Enrique Abeyta

The market has felt unstoppable lately, but it won’t last forever. In fact, it could come to an end at any moment.
Death By Greed: Silver Edition

Death By Greed: Silver Edition

Posted October 14, 2025

By Ian Culley

Silver is trading at record highs. But that doesn’t mean you need to rush out and buy.
Everyone Loves the Rally…. Except the Data

Everyone Loves the Rally…. Except the Data

Posted October 13, 2025

By Enrique Abeyta

Stocks have been on a hot streak. But a few key indicators are starting to show cracks in the foundation.
How to Handle a Bubble — You Have Four Options

How to Handle a Bubble — You Have Four Options

Posted October 09, 2025

By Enrique Abeyta

You don’t have to be a market expert to spot a bubble. The hard part is knowing what to do about it.