Print the page
Increase font size
Before You Buy: Your Checklist for a Perfect Trade

Posted February 24, 2025

Enrique Abeyta

By Enrique Abeyta

Before You Buy: Your Checklist for a Perfect Trade

The smart money will tell you that you can’t beat the market.

They’ll say the only way for you to succeed is to simply give them your money and let them run it for you.

They are WRONG. With a great system and a great process, you can generate strong returns.

That is why I’ve developed a proprietary system to identify trade setups with the highest probability of success.

I previously walked through the 15-point scoring system I use to identify trades, using a real example from our trading service The Maverick.

It’s simple: The more points a stock scores, the higher the probability that it will be a profitable trade.

Over the years, the system has done very well, with hit rates exceeding 70% across the board.

In fact, the most recent iteration of our software has produced an 80% success rate for stocks scoring a rare “15/15.”

Last week, we dove into our analysis's technical or price-driven side. I shared the 6 points we look at from a technical perspective.

Stocks that only hit these 6 points are usually great bets. But what makes this system even more powerful is that we don’t stop there.

Here is the rest of my checklist for a perfect “15/15” trade.

The Fundamentals, Starting With EPS Growth

In addition to the technicals that I outlined last time, our system also looks at a company’s fundamentals.

This means the operating performance of the company —how they are performing in terms of revenue, cash flow, and earnings.

This analysis is key because investors buy stocks with the belief that they are buying the business.

Businesses that are growing and performing well are more attractive to investors.

In my analysis, I look at how the company has done recently to figure out which stocks are the most attractive.

First, I look at growth.

You will hear a lot of “rules” of what makes stocks go up, but I will tell you there is one that ALWAYS works — growth.

Find a company that is growing earnings from $1 per share to $10 per share, and you will find a stock that is going UP.

It might go up a little or a lot. It might go up now, or it might go up later. In all scenarios, though, it is going up.

In our system, we go back and look at the previous three years of results for revenue, cash flow, and earnings.

We are looking for 75% of those 12 (three years of quarters) data points to be higher year-over-year. If this is true, we assign one point for each of these three financial metrics.

Going back to our “perfect stock” from last week, Brown & Brown Inc. (BRO), here is a table showing the quarterly EPS results over the last three years.

BRO has grown every quarter except one.

These are the results for EPS, but the results for revenue and cash flow (as measured by EBITDA) are the same. This is how BRO scored three points on this measure.

Earnings Beats

Next, we are looking at how a company performs versus expectations.

Companies that do better than expectations will usually have strong stocks.

This is driven by human psychology. Would you rather own a company that is consistently doing BETTER than you expected or one that is doing WORSE?

Without trying to be intellectual about the answer, the fact is people want to own companies that are doing better.

Like growth, we look back at the previous 12 quarters and look for a company that has beat analysts’ expectations for at least 75% of those quarters.

Here is a table showing the data on EPS for BRO.

The results are identical to the growth results. The company has beat expectations every quarter except one over the last three years.

The same is true for their revenue and cash flow. This is how it earned another three points on its way to a “15/15” perfect score.

Upward Revisions

Finally, I look at what are called earnings revisions.

All the large companies in the stock market have many Wall Street analysts who cover the stock. Part of their research is building financial models where they attempt to predict future results.

These predictions (called estimates) are what many investors use to value a stock. In theory, the value of a stock is the value of its future cash flows, so this makes sense.

When a company is beating numbers, the analysts will then move their future estimates higher. This should mean that the stock is more valuable.

In practice, this is one of the most powerful driving forces in the stock market.

In particular, we are looking for companies that show at least three consecutive positive earnings revisions. Stocks that exhibit that pattern often will see explosive future returns.

Here is a chart showing the stock price of BRO along with the revisions for 2025 EPS.

On the chart, you can see that these estimates have moved up consistently over the last few years. You can also see that the stock has moved up with them.

I also noted on the chart when we made our “buy” recommendation to our readers.

Like the growth metrics and performance versus expectations, the estimates have moved higher for BRO, not just on EPS but also on revenue and cash flow.

This is how it scored another three points and completed the “15/15” perfect score.

Warren Buffett, Signing Off One Last Time

Warren Buffett, Signing Off One Last Time

Posted November 10, 2025

By Enrique Abeyta

In light of Buffett’s final letter to shareholders as CEO, let’s revisit a few of his timeless (though not universal) bits of advice.
3 Beaten-Down Charts Ready to Bounce

3 Beaten-Down Charts Ready to Bounce

Posted November 07, 2025

By Greg Guenthner

These three areas have gotten absolutely hammered. But they could be setting up for a bounce by next week.
Wisdom of a FinTwit Oracle

Wisdom of a FinTwit Oracle

Posted November 06, 2025

By Enrique Abeyta

Ed Borgato may be one of the most insightful investors that you’ve never heard of.
Give Gold a Rest (and Trade This Miner Instead)

Give Gold a Rest (and Trade This Miner Instead)

Posted November 04, 2025

By Ian Culley

Gold acts as a leading indicator for other commodities. Based on past cycles, expect a rally in metals like lithium soon.
When Seasonality Meets "Situationality"

When Seasonality Meets "Situationality"

Posted November 03, 2025

By Enrique Abeyta

How does the market perform heading into year-end when it’s already running hot? Let’s take a look at the data.
Is the Melt-Up on the Ropes?!

Is the Melt-Up on the Ropes?!

Posted October 31, 2025

By Greg Guenthner

If the choppy market action is making you nervous… Relax. Melt-up season is still a go!